Review: St. Regis Bal Harbour

In the interest of full disclosure, One Mile At A Time earns a referral bonus for anyone that’s approved through some of the below links. These are the best publicly available offers that we have found for each card. Please check out our advertiser policy for further details about the partners we work with. Thanks for your support!

Up front I’d like to disclose that my room was paid for by the Starwood Preferred Guest® Credit Card from American Express (that’s my affiliate link) as part of the AmEx Stars program that I’m participating in this year.

Not only does it give me a lot of great opportunities, but for each experience I have, a reader gets an equally awesome one. Tomorrow I’ll be launching a contest (courtesy of the Starwood American Express) for 60,000 SPG points, enough for two nights at the St. Regis Bal Harbour.

The St. Regis Bal Harbour opened earlier this year and was named Forbes’ most anticipated hotel opening of 2012, so there’s no doubt that they had big shoes to fill and that my expectations were high.

One of the butlers from the hotel emailed me about a week before my stay to see if I had any special requests, which I thought was a nice touch. I responded with my anticipated arrival time, along with a request for late check-out and a room upgrade (due to Starwood Platinum status). They responded within hours acknowledging the request for both, saying my reservation had been notated.

We pulled up to the St. Regis at around 1PM and were immediately welcomed by the valet and bellmen. The hotel is part of a larger three building complex. The two buildings on the sides are both luxury condos, and in the center is the St. Regis. As you can see from the view from the front of the hotel, the exterior of the St. Regis is just a blank wall, given that all the rooms have an ocean view, so the front side is really the “back side” of the hotel.


Hotel entrance


Hotel exterior

Once inside the stunning lobby we were directed to check-in, which wasn’t the traditional counter you stand at, but rather individual desks for a more personalized experience.


Lobby


Lobby


Check-in area


Art in check-in area

The associate that helped us was exceedingly professional and friendly, and spent a few minutes looking at upgrade options for us. She said she found a Grand Luxe Oceanfront Suite that was available, though it would be about an hour before it was ready, which worked for us.

During the check-in process we were offered champagne and cold towels from our butler, who introduced herself to us at that point.


Welcome drink

After check-in was complete the associate suggested we have lunch in the restaurant, which we agreed to since we hadn’t eaten. Instead of merely pointing us to the restaurant she walked us there, and introduced us to the host at the restaurant by name.

I’ve gotta stop right here for a second and say that the first 15 minutes of the stay absolutely blew me away. I’ve experienced this level of service in Asia, but never, ever in the US. Every single employee I interacted with referred to me by my last name, “sir,” or “gentlemen.” Furthermore, while it’s tough to describe, all of the employees I had interacted with at the hotel were not only extremely polished in their interactions, but at the same time personable and sincere, which can be a very tough balance to strike.

We had lunch at J&G Grill, where the great service continued. I initially had a bit of “sticker shock” at the prices – the bottle of tap water was $5 and a Diet Coke was $6, but the views and service were amazing. I had a short rib calzone for lunch (it was a special), while my friend had a shrimp salad, both of which were very good.


View from J &G Grill


Calzone


Shrimp salad

As we finished lunch the associate from the front desk called me to advise us our room was ready.

We headed back to the check-in area, where our butler, Marine, was waiting for us.

Marine showed us how the elevators work, which are pretty high tech. You never push a floor number, but instead just scan your key when you want to enter the elevator and it takes you to your floor.


Elevator controls


Elevator controls

The other interesting touch about suites is that the elevator door opens right in front of your suite. The elevators all have doors on both sides. If you have a standard room the elevator opens to the hallway, while if you have a suite the other door opens, which leads to a small room with the entrance to the two suites on each floor. Even though it doesn’t have any practical implications, it’s still totally awesome.

Marina gave us a tour of the suite and explained all the features. All I can say is “WOW!”

I’ve been fortunate enough to stay at a lot of great hotels, but this had to be one of the most stunning rooms ever.

Upon entering was the living and dining room. First was the dining room, which featured a large table as well as a pretty extensive kitchen with a huge fridge, stove, sink, and enough silverware to last a month.


Suite entrance


Living and dining room


Living and dining room


Minibar


Fridge


Silverware and cutlery

That led to the living room, which featured a comfortable couch facing a flat screen TV along with two chairs and ottomans.


Living room


Living room


Living room

Just past that was the balcony, which was huge. That has to be the most stunning aspect of the hotel – every room has a balcony, and they’re all huge and face the Atlantic Ocean. The one downside due to the design is that they have very little privacy, though that wasn’t a huge issue for me, and it’s a small price to pay for every room having a huge balcony facing the ocean.


Living room balcony


View from living room balcony


View from living room balcony


View from living room balcony

Going back to the living and dining room, there was also a second bathroom with a huge shower right by the entrance.


Second bathroom


Second bathroom

The bedroom was equally stunning, with a comfortable bed, nice seating area, and an equally spacious balcony.


Bedroom


Bedroom


Bedroom

The room controls were also high tech, as everything could be controlled from the remote the next to the bed.


Room controls


Bedroom balcony

Between the bedroom and master bathroom was plenty of storage space and closets.


Closets and storage space

I also loved the bathroom, which featured double sinks, a huge tub, and a large shower with a rainforest shower head. All of the toiletries were Remede branded.


Master bathroom


Master bathroom


Bathtub


Shower

The mirror even had a built in TV.


Master bathroom


Toiletries

Impressively enough the suite also featured a washer and dryer, which is not something you see often in hotel suites (it would have been more useful if my stay was more than two nights!).

After settling into the room I decided to tour the hotel a bit, starting on the ballroom floor, which is where the pool, spa, and gym are located.

The gym is open 24 hours/day and is separated into a cardio and weights section which can be accessed separately. The hotel is brand new, so as you’d expect they had top of the line equipment. The gym overlooks the pool and ocean, so it’s not all that bad of a place to get some exercise.


Gym


Gym

The pool itself is nothing special and I feel they could have done a bit more with the design, though I thought the area surround the pool was beautifully designed. Finding seating near the pool was never an issue, and there are several employees roaming to assist, be it with towels or any other service items (they provide free water and sunscreen at the pool).


Main pool


Main pool


Main pool

While the main pool is reasonably well visited there’s also a tranquility pool for adults, which has virtually the same design though was empty each time I visited. There’s also a hot tub there. I don’t care how hot it is outside, I love hot tubs.


Tranquility pool


Hot tub

Just past the pool was the beach. As you approach the beach you’re asked for your room number and name, and the staff there set up lounge chairs based on your preferences.

I’m not usually a beach person, but I was out there both days till I looked like the mascot of my favorite chain seafood restaurant (anyone want to guess). 😉

The beach itself was beautiful, and the water was nice and warm, so it was a great place to disconnect.


Beach


Water and sunscreen


Hotel from beach

It’s interesting to note that the crowd at the hotel was extremely international. I’d say less than 10% of the guests were actually American, while 30% were Russian, 30% were Brazilian, and the rest were from Mexico, Europe, etc.

As a Starwood Platinum member I had chosen breakfast as the Platinum amenity, which is served daily at Atlantico from 7AM to 11AM. The restaurant was a bit on the small side, and one morning we had to wait about 15 minutes for a table.

On the plus side the spread and service were very good. Platinum status gets you a continental breakfast, which was more than adequate, between the fruit, pastries, bagels, lox, etc.


Atlantico


Atlantico outdoor seating


Buffet


Buffet


Buffet

St. Regis also offers butler service, which I’ve never really found a use for. I don’t want someone else packing and unpacking my bags, and I’m not sure what else they’re supposed to do. The one value I do find in the service is the complimentary coffee and tea, which I ordered both afternoons. The service was quick and setup nice.


Complimentary tea service

It’s also worth noting that the hotel is across the street from the Bal Harbour Shops, which has plenty of dining options and, you guessed it, shops.

The hotel doesn’t have self parking and valet parking is $38 per day, which seems pretty steep to me since this isn’t really a “city” location, but I guess it’s in line with the rest of the prices. This is the one complaint I had about the hotel. The valets were pretty slow, which I’m fine with, but I was more concerned with how they drove, which I’d say was borderline reckless. They drove around the driveway to the hotel at speeds that were far too fast for an area with pedestrians, and also accelerated and decelerated at unnecessary rates. I certainly wouldn’t treat my car that way, and I expect other people not to either. I brought it up with the front desk staff at about midnight on a Saturday night when I returned to the hotel, and immediately received a call from the manager on duty who promised to look into it. The next day the director of parking contacted me to thank me for my feedback and apologize, which I appreciated.

No hotel is perfect, but it’s the way they handled the situation that impressed me.

At check-out there was a short wait for an associate, and as I was waiting I was approached by the concierge who asked if I needed any directions, dining suggestions, or a boarding pass print, which really impressed me.

So yeah, the St. Regis Bal Harbour is a stunning property. Physically it’s one of the most beautiful properties I’ve ever stayed at, but more than anything else it was the service that set the hotel apart. With the exception of my issue with the valet, every single employee gave me the impression that they genuinely wanted to exceed expectations. And it wasn’t just that they were friendly, but they were confident, personable, and extremely professional, to a degree I’ve never before experienced at a hotel in the US.

This hotel is a winner, and most definitely deserves it’s position on Forbes’ list of most anticipated hotel openings 2012.

Stay tuned till tomorrow for your chance to win 60,000 SPG points courtesy of the Starwood American Express, enough for a two-night stay at the St. Regis Bal Harbour (or stays at just about any Starwood property worldwide).

Enjoy this review? Check out hundreds of other reports on airlines, hotels, and airport lounges worldwide!

Regarding Comments: The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

Comments

  1. Although it looks like a great hotel , its hard to take this review unbaised since it was paid by amex thru their program.

  2. Lucky,

    Just out of curiosity: did the hotel know that you were going to be doing a write up of them ahead of time?

  3. I’d rather they had just conducted a good facelift of the Sheraton Bal Harbour. That pool area was great. The Miami Beach area is missing a hotel at the Sheraton’s old price point where you could just go and unwind. Now for the price the St. Regis charges I’d rather just stay down at the Delano, Setai or Ritz.

  4. Lovely photos and I enjoyed reading your review. It looks like a lovely property with fine amenities.

  5. This was the dealbreaker for my wife and my recent visit to Miami Beach:

    “The St. Regis Bal Harbour Resort, Miami Beach is located on the edge of the Atlantic just 15 minutes north of South Beach.” It is way too far north…

    Lucky – why did you have to negotiate the room upgrade / worry about paying for breakfast (Continental or Full)? Didn’t they comp you everything for your stay?

    Thanks for your clear disclosure… Even taking potential bias in to account, the property itself looks impressive.

  6. Thanks for the review, Ben. Is this your best SPG upgrade/stay?

    Also, do you think it’s worth 30K SPG pts? That is a lot…like their best AMEX CC offer, or 35K AA miles.

    My gf likes the Bal Harbour shops, but still…

  7. Is that a hot pockets that they served you for lunch, looks like it came from a vending machine!

  8. Lucky, if you had to pay your way for this stay, either points, cash, or a combination of both, would you stay here again?

  9. Lucky Lucky. Very nice, indeed. Great report and pics. I agree with the others about the location–certainly not prime for anything “fun” (South Beach) or interesting. Many of the overseas guests probably don’t realize that, however.

  10. I like to self park my car and do not like hotels that have no self park option. I do not like parking valets to drive my car in a reckless manner (too fast, etc).

    I would rather park on a nearby street and save the excess valet fee. It may not be feasible to park on the street nearby at this hotel.

  11. How much was your room and how many points does it take for your room? Without that context, your review has no context for us schmoes without your contacts

  12. Let’s all give Lucky a break, regardless the AMEX SPG card connection, the hotel review s great, I have to point out one thing so, is there any further protection on the balcony? I’m afraid of heights, and it’s given me dizziness just looking at that balcony shot.

  13. Ben, Nice review bu i think you were given extra treatment that is not the norm at the property. I’ve been there twice already and was never addressed by name or given champagne at check in. And as a platinum I was told twice that no suites available, even though it was fairly obvious that they were

  14. As a recovering alcoholic, I find it rather amusing that the “free” booze on display seems to invite excessive consumption. Or maybe I’m just jealous I can’t drink for free.

  15. “my favorite chain seafood restaurant (anyone want to guess)”

    Red Lobster. Where are the Miss Florida pictures 😉

  16. @ storm – reminds me of that white deer from Harry Potter…

    Pricing: If you have to ask, it’s too expensive… 🙂 (December stay, high season: least expensive $809 / night. Oceanfront Suite $2K / night. Royal Ocenfront Suite $2,600 / night, but it is almost 2,000 sf…)

    Or, 30,000 points for the least expensive room. (cash + points: 15,000 points + $275)

  17. @David That was my thought too. The only suite upgrade I ever got as a SPG Plat is at St. Regis Princeville to a Junior suite. It seems quite often they just give one level basic upgrade and be done with it even if there are better rooms available. As a Hyatt Diamond, I was offered a suite upgrade at a Hyatt Regency if I am willing to use my upgrade certificate but will only put me on a club floor on a complimentary basis. The upgrade policies are very much a miss with a rate hit in my case. I believe travel bloggers get the upgrades more often than regular public relatively.

  18. Nice review !

    Is it only me or the built-in tv in the bathroom is really in a weird location (you can’t watch it from the tube, and its not in front of the double sinks so while shaving you gotta turn your head to the right )? Makes it pretty useless if so ..

  19. @BR That’s Portuguese, not Spanish. The third option says “Languages,” so I assume lucky was switching the languages around or the previous guest was one of the many wealthy Brazilians who vacation in the area.

  20. Great report, Lucky. This property used to be the Sheraton Ball harbour, which was demolished to accomodate the new complex. Although the location seems to be rather un- attractive to your readers, it is worth noting that for latin americans, especially Brazilians, anything near the Bal Harbour shops is great. Brazilians -and also russians, are perhaps the turists with higher expenditures in Florida.

  21. @ TheBeerHunter — Ultimately I have no way of knowing (keep in mind it wasn’t SPG comping the stay, but rather the Starwood American Express), so I’m not sure. On one hand I’d think they would, but on the other hand I didn’t feel like there was anything “out of the ordinary” to indicate that they did.

    @ Lark — Nope, only the room was covered. I had to pay for everything else.

    @ David — It’s definitely up there! The thing about the hotel is that revenue rates are often reasonable (~$350-400 with FHR benefits) in the off season, so I think that’s usually a better value. If you’re staying five nights the value gets a bit better on points, since the fifth night is free.

  22. @ ORD-TGU — Hah, it was actually surprisingly good.

    @ Truthiness — If I got a good rate in the off season I’d definitely stay again. Otherwise if I had a special occasion and wanted to stay five nights on points (with the fifth night free) I’d also consider it. This hotel is usually out of my budget, though.

    @ Michael — The room I was booked into was roughly 30K SPG points or $400, and then I got an upgrade from there.

    @ Usairelire — You got it!

    @ KevinZ — Thanks! Nope, that was the extent of the railing. I hate heights as well, though I think the railing is higher than it looks.

    @ David — I can’t comment on the other points, though every single person I saw checked in was offered champagne.

  23. @ BR — Hah, I think I pushed the wrong button by mistake.

    @ danray — No, it wasn’t.

    @ Storm — “Art?”

    @ vincentb89 — It could definitely be better located near the bathtub or between the sinks. Totally agree.

  24. Lucky–I may have missed it, but it may be helpful for some readers (me!) in the future if you clearly state where the hotel is. I had no idea where the hell Bal Harbor was until I read some of the comments, where I deduced it’s somewhere in the Miami area. Thanks!

  25. Did a staycation over the past weekend. Was not upgraded as a Platinum. Was told they only upgrade to Junior Suites and that if I wanted to upgrade, I could pay for it. The room order of $175 was incorrect and it was the first time I spend $175 on room service where I was actually hungry after eating. A few days later I received an updated folio with an extra $13.64 honor bar charge. We did not use the honor bar. I brought my own bar with me. Overall…not very impressed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *